Forum Topic
dsjohnson84
MemberOvomorphMay-29-2012 4:43 PMWith the "Shaw takes the alien craft with David to go to the Engineer homeworld" in mind, I give you this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHe0LxBOkq4&feature=youtu.be
6 Replies
Xenomorpheus
MemberOvomorphMay-29-2012 5:04 PMHahaha. You have managed to perfectly summarise exactly what I thought when I heard that was part of the film's plot. Awesome.
dsjohnson84
MemberOvomorphMay-29-2012 5:15 PMI thank the creators of South Park and a friend of mine for reminding me of this clip, I'm glad it was online! viva la internet!
And yes, this is exactly what I was thinking too... so perfect. I mean really? WTF is she gonna do?
Xenomorpheus
MemberOvomorphMay-29-2012 5:40 PMI guess there's still every chance it could be bogus. The Wikipedia plot was taken down and there's some conflicting stories between some of the people that claim to have seen the film but I think the main plot of the film is now out in the open.
I don't have any problem with the idea of her travelling to the SJ homeworld for her answers, but the idea that she can single handedly stop a civilisation as advanced as the Engineer's would be laughable. Would literally be exactly like that Family Guy scene. Which I am still laughing at.
dsjohnson84
MemberOvomorphMay-29-2012 6:00 PMYeah you are right, it could still be bogus, but like you said, there is enough evidence to validate the main plot points.
I don't mind that she wants to go there for answers... fine. But where this starts to get a little crazy for me is: #1 How is she flying this ancient alien craft? I thought she was a scientist, not a pilot. I doubt David's HEAD is flying this thing. #2 Again, what does she think she is going to achieve by going there? Reasoning? Diplomacy? Perhaps she simply just wants answers and is ok with possibly dying afterwards. #3 What is she going to eat? Drink? On her journey? How will she survive? Cryo? Ok... but after that?
It just seems a little ehhhh for me. I feel that a team of writers + Ridley could have invented something a little better. I can't even imagine where a second film would lead us... but if it's ONE human character interacting with a bunch of Aliens... ehhhh again.
Myrddin365
MemberFacehuggerMay-29-2012 6:43 PMAWESOME! lol!
Safe? Of course he isn't safe, but he's good!
Add A Reply
