Log in to unlock your profile!

Is Judge Dredd: Mega-City One a good idea?

Scified2017-10-21 13:59:49http://www.scified.com/articles/is-judge-dredd-mega-city-one-good-idea-0.jpg
Scified
Is Judge Dredd: Mega-City One a good idea?
Dredd movie news, trailers and cast

Dredd September 7th, 2012

Rebellion, the video game developer behind the Sniper Elite series and the 2010 Aliens versus Predator video game, who also own 2000 AD and Judge Dredd announced in May that they were developing a TV serial of the cult comic book titled Judge Dredd: Mega-City One. Speaking on the 2000 AD Thrillcast producer Brian Jenkins, and executive producer Jason Kingsley announced that the TV serial, being very early in its development is still a couple of years away from release, is planned to be a big budget, character-focused production, filmed in the UK and to be distributed by IM Global. During a sometimes chaotic discussion Rebellion co-founder Kingsley and producer Jenkins stated that concept art and early drafts of the episodes are in development that will pull from decades of 2000 AD comics as well as introduce new elements created specifically for the show.

Amidst the banter Kingsley and Jenkins acknowledged that the 1995 movie Judge Dredd starring Sylvester Stallone while being "campy" was aesthetically closer to the look and lore of the comic book source material, the 2012 movie Dredd successfully recreated the tone and atmosphere of the characters, especially with Karl Urban's portrayal of Judge Dredd. Speaking of the Australian born actor both Kingsley and Jenkins stated that while they are hopeful that Urban will reprise the role of Mega-City One's most famous Judge, although they expect scheduling conflicts may make the possibility unlikely. Reportedly due to feature an ensemble cast the show is expected to be released in 2019/2020.

Due to its underwhelming performance at the box office, it is unsurprising that Rebellion has moved away from developing a sequel to the 2012 movie, yet while their enthusiasm and reverence for the Judge Dredd property cannot be denied, is a small screen adaptation of the world of Mega-City One really a good idea? Consider the nature of the source material, which is graphically violent, socially satirical but also quite often frankly insane, which is a fine line that even the comic book struggles to navigate. Will such a property adapted to the small screen appeal to a wide enough audience and become profitable enough to warrant a renewal for a second season? Or, is it more likely that the show will be considered too abstract (like Hannibal), will underperform and fail to deliver (a la Gotham), or just become another procedural police show.

Subjectively looking at the Mega City and Judge Dredd property and at Rebellion it does seem somewhat surprising that the company is not playing towards its strengths and adapting the property as an AAA video game title. Such a title set within a vast online open-world Mega-City One, in which players co-operatively maintain order and dispense the law as Judges, battling against violent gangs, demonic entities and sentient vegetables could become a possible GTA V and Destiny beater, and could even allow favored star Urban to reprise his role with minimal scheduling issues via voice-over work. Rebellion could use their already well-established development and publishing teams together with their premier intellectual property to create and deliver, without physical restriction a leading long-term AAA video game title.

 

Regardless it seems Rebellion are pushing forward with their Judge Dredd: Mega-City One series and only time will tell as to whether the characters third live-action incarnation proves favorable with audiences or whether, as with previous adaptations fails to live up to the charm and character of the iconic comic book original.

Stay up to date with the latest news on Pete Travis's Dredd movie by liking Scified on Facebook and by following us on Twitter and Instagram! Also, consider subscribing your email to our Judge Dredd News blog for instant notifications of when new posts are made!

Related Judge Dredd News Articles

Judge Dredd Co-Creator John Wager Reveals That Fox Passed On A Spinoff Film Featuring Judge DeathScified2016-10-03 11:54:06/articles/sm/judge-dredd-co-creator-john-wager-reveals-that-fox-passed-on-a-spinoff-film-featuring-judge-death-66.jpg
Scified
Judge Dredd Co-Creator John Wager Reveals That Fox Passed On A Spinoff Film Featuring Judge Death

Judge Dredd Co-Creator John Wager Reveals That Fox Passed On A Spinoff Film Featuring Judge Death

Judge Dredd co-creator John Wager has revealed that 20th Century Fox passed on a spinoff movie featuring series antagonist Judge Death. Speaking to Screen Geek at 2000 AD’s ... Read More

Updated - Is Dredd 2 in development?Scified2016-06-22 02:31:05/articles/sm/karl-urban-says-that-dredd-2-is-in-development-12.jpg
Scified
Updated - Is Dredd 2 in development?

Updated - Is Dredd 2 in development?

As reported by Science Fiction.com Karl Urban, while speaking at the Denver City Comic Con, confirmed that a long-awaited sequel to Dredd is indeed in production, although whether ... Read More

Could Dredd be coming to Netflix or Amazon?Scified2016-05-02 14:40:57/articles/sm/could-dredd-be-coming-to-netflix-or-amazon-23.jpg
Scified
Could Dredd be coming to Netflix or Amazon?

Could Dredd be coming to Netflix or Amazon?

2012's Dredd starring Karl Urban, Olivia Thirlby, and Lena Headey may have become a cult classic among Judge Dredd fans but having only earned $41.5 million in worldwide box office... Read More

Alex Garland Moves On From Dredd!Scified2015-03-19 05:25:38/articles/sm//sites_pics/273129700360912.png
Scified
Alex Garland Moves On From Dredd!

Alex Garland Moves On From Dredd!

Alex Garland, writer and producer of 2012's cult movie Dredd was present at the SXSW promoting Ex Machinima, his directorial debut. Collider caught up with him and asked the writer... Read More

Judge Dredd Bootleg Universe Cartoons Released!Scified2014-10-27 12:17:24/articles/sm//sites_pics/5428123112455304.png
Scified
Judge Dredd Bootleg Universe Cartoons Released!

Judge Dredd Bootleg Universe Cartoons Released!

While star Karl Urban and 2000ad themselves are confident that a live action sequel to 2012's cult classic Dredd is still very much a viable possibility, executive producer Adi Sha... Read More

0 Fan responses to Is Judge Dredd: Mega-City One a good idea?
Please sign in to add a comment
Visitor Comments
  • Forum Stats
  • Members
  • 74 Recently Online
  • Forum Topics
  • Replies

© 2017 Scified.com, All Rights Reserved

Your account has not yet been verified. Please check your email for the verification link to begin posting.

Please review our rules before sharing content

Use Your E-Mail:


Password:


Stay Logged In

Content Policies & Legal Disclaimers